It Is A Human Right Of Person Accused Of Sexual Harassment To Get Info To Defend Himself, Says CIC; Penalises “Penny-wise” CPIO


The Central Information Commission (CIC) has held that it is the human right of a person accused of sexual harassment in his capacity as a citizen and accused under the RTI Act and under the principles of criminal justice, to get all the related information to defend himself in a penal proceedings while imposing a penalty of Rs 25,000 on a Public Information Officer for denying the information to an officer accused of sexual harassment at workplace and recommended disciplinary enquiry be conducted against him.

CIC Madabhushi Sridhar Acharyulu also criticised the CPIO for demanding Rs. 6 for three pages supplied to the appellant by writing a letter, as the CIC said, “The RTI Rules say the CPIO can collect the copying fee at Rs 2 per page but did not authorize him to demand Rs 2 by spending more than that. This reflects at least, the harassing nature of the CPIO, which is surely a sign of malice. The problem of CPIO is the mindset and attitude. It is part of malice.”

“It is the human right of the appellant in his capacity as a citizen and accused under RTI Act and under the principles of criminal justice, to all the related information to defend himself in penal proceedings. The expression ‘human rights’ is defined in Section 2(d) of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993. “human rights” means the rights relating to life liberty, equality and dignity of the individual guaranteed by the Constitution or embodied in the International Covenants and enforceable by courts in India,” said Acharyulu.

“There are, in fact, two human rights—one, right to defend himself in penal proceedings and second, right to information to prepare for that defence. These two human rights are founded on a) principles of natural justice and due process, b) principles of criminal justice, c) the provisions of SHW Act of 2013, d) the provisions of RTI Act 2005,” he added.

The CIC was hearing an appeal moved by an officer facing an inquiry on a complaint of alleged sexual harassment. He had sought information on 15 points, including copies of Statements of the named individuals obtained by the Internal Complaints Committee (ICC) during the preliminary inquiry and copies of correspondences between an official and the president of the ICC.

While the CPIO denied him the information, three documents were given to the appellant which included a copy of the order by which ICC, Mandsaur, was formed, a copy of order by which a particular member of ICC was placed on superannuation list and a copy of his retirement charge report.

The CPIO also wrote to the appellant to pay Rs. 6 for a page.

To the CIC’s surprise, the appellant was denied the other information by the CPIO citing Section 16 of the Sexual Harassment at Workplace Act, 2013 which is prohibition of publication of information to and by the media about the identity and addresses of aggrieved woman, respondent and witnesses during the conciliation and inquiry proceedings, and action taken etc.

The CIC noted that “the provision does not mean that information could be denied to respondent-accused. Hence denial of information sought by the appellant is in clear breach of all above provisions of SHW Act of 2013”.

The CPIO also invoked exemption clauses 8(1)(d) and (g) of RTI Act to deny the appellant the information, which the CIC said, should have been given as per principles of natural justice, rules of disciplinary inquiry, Act of 2013, Rules made thereunder, official handbook of the Ministry containing guidelines for prevention of Sexual Harassment. The CPIO used exemption clauses under the RTI Act also.

Section 8(1)(d) of RTI Act says; information including commercial confidence, trade secrets or intellectual property, the disclosure of which would harm the competitive position of a third party, unless the competent authority is satisfied that larger public interest warrants the disclosure of such information.

Section 8(1)(g) says: information, the disclosure of which would endanger the life or physical safety of any person or identify the source of information or assistance given in confidence for law enforcement or security purposes.

The first appellate authority also upheld the denial of information.
The appellant moved the CIC saying as a charge-sheeted accused before ICC, the principles of natural justice demand that certified copies of all documents relating to the inquiry report, including copies of the statements of witnesses, should be given to him to facilitate him to substantiate his defence and for the conduct of the inquiry in a fair manner.

How are statement of witnesses a trade secret?
The CIC observed, “The CPIO neither explained nor justified how these clauses could be invoked in this case. He has not applied his mind at all. How the statement of witnesses and other documents relating to sexual harassment complaint could be considered as ‘trade secret’, ‘commercial confidence’ or ‘intellectual property’ of the third party or public authority? This is absolute absurdity.
“The appellant himself gave the names of the four witnesses and asked for their statements of evidence given during inquiry. This information was denied under an excuse that their physical security is threatened. These excuses are laughable and amounts to misuse of law by authority to deny the right to information of the appellant. It also reflects malafide on the part of the CPIO. If this is the way information is denied and accused is not allowed to defend, false allegations will increase and real purpose of Act of 2013 and RTI Act will be totally defeated.”

“The charge of sexual harassment is a serious allegation which if falsely made and proved by suppression of information to the accused, it can ruin the career of the accused, cause permanent and irreparable damage to the reputation and also disturb his domestic life affecting his relations with his wife and children. Society will look him down and people talk badly about him in his absence or some may even insult him openly. As per SHW Act 2013, he would be shifted, and he might even face criminal prosecution under IPC which in our country would span over a decade or more involving huge expenditure and going to courts for several rounds as an accused person. A false allegation can render his life a hell for the accused officer and if innocent, the officer might suffer serious mental torture also. It can destroy a person totally. The due process, principles of natural justice and legal provisions of the SHW Act of 2013 provide him a right to defend himself from allegation of sexual harassment, and the right to information to secure those related documents will strengthen that right”.

Referring to the Supreme Court verdict in Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India in which it was held that right to live under Article 21 is not merely a physical right but includes within its ambit the right to live with human dignity, the CIC said, “An unproven charge of sexual harassment seriously affects the dignity of a person. And not facilitating the procedural rights including right to information/documents that are being used against him will deprive him of a due opportunity to defend himself, which is the human right to free and fair trial that amount to breach of Article 21.”
The CIC also referred to various provisions of the CrPC and also the Sixth Amendment to the US Constitution which provide for an accused to be informed of the nature and causes of accusations and the right to cross-examine while being allowed to put the witness in his defence.

It also referred to another recent judgment of CIC in M Dinesh v PIO, Bureau of Immigration/Intelligence Bureau, wherein it was held that it was a human right of the accused facing inquiry to have complete information.

“By denying the information the appellant was not only harassed by the public authority, but also by the CPIO. While public authority denied him the documents which he was entitled under SHW Act of 2013, the CPIO denied them under RTI Act besides wrongfully invoking Section 8(1) (d) and (g). It is absurd to think that copy of inquiry report and statements of witnesses could be ‘trade secret’, ‘intellectual property’ or of ‘commercial confidence’,” said Acharyulu.
A pennywise CPIO
“The CPIO was penny wise when he demanded Rs 6 to give 3 pages. The CPIO might have spent at least Rs 15 to Rs 100 approximately (taking into account the time, energy, paper, typing or correcting mistakes, which is quite possible, and posting) to write a letter demanding Rs 6. If it is his personal money, no prudent man would spend Rs 100 for collecting Rs 6. Is it not wrongful spending of public money? If this CPIO is demanding money up to Rs 18, by spending Rs 20 to Rs 100 every day hypothetically, what should be the loss of exchequer per year? Even if the appellant positively responds and pays Rs 6 promptly, still the loss would be Rs 94. The RTI Rules say the CPIO can collect the copying fee at Rs 2 per page but do not authorize him to demand Rs 2 by spending more than that. This reflects at least, the harassing nature of the CPIO, which is surely a sign of malice,” said the CPIO.
Read the Order Here

Share :

Facebook Twitter Google+
0 Comments on "It Is A Human Right Of Person Accused Of Sexual Harassment To Get Info To Defend Himself, Says CIC; Penalises “Penny-wise” CPIO"

You are also part of the Postal Family. Please Reply for the below query

Follow by Email

Popular Posts

You Might Like the following Tags in PoTools.

.Net Removal Tool .Net setup 15G / 15H 7thCPC 80C Aadhaar Card Aadhaar Fees Aadhar Software AAO Abolish of Posts Abstract Accountant Exam Accounts Accounts and Finance Service accounts error Accounts MIS Accounts Officer accounts PBS ACG-17 ACG-61 Active Directory AD AD Rollout Adhoc Promotion Admit Card for Postman Exam Advances Advertisement Adware Removal Tool Agent Portal Agent software Agreement Tool AIO installer All in One Drivers Allowance Alphabet Amazon AMC ammyy admin AMPC Android android indiapost Annual Property Returns Annual Report Anomalies in 7th CPC Answer Key antivirus Anubhav APAR Appeal Application Form Architectural Assistant Army Postal Service Assets & Liabilities Atal Pension Yojana ATM Automatic Credit Automatic Mailer AV Rollout Average Balance Bad Sector Bajaj Auto Finance balance verification Bandwidth of Post Offices Bank News Barcode Barcode Scanner BCP beta version BHIM Bhuvan India Post Bifurcation Bill Mail Service Biometric Black Money Blacklists BNPL BNPL Bill Generation bnpl Parcel BO Account verification Tool BO Finacle BO Mapping BO Rules BO Slip BO Tag Bonus News Bonus Order Book of Information Book Value Bootable USB BPM BPM Recruitment Management System branch office Bridge Plugin Broadband Application Browser BSNL Budget Budget 2016 Bulk eMO Payment Bulk Upload Burn CD Burn DVD Business Development Business Hours Business Parcel Business Post Centre Business Reply Speed Post Cabinet Approval Cable TV Cadre Restructuring Cadre Review Calendars Calenders 2016 Call Centre Cancellation of Examination Cannon 6108 Printer Cash Balance Cash Book Error Cash Conveyance Cash Counting Machine Cash Flow Cashless Transactions Casual Labour Casual Leave CAT Case CAT Judgement CBI CBS CBS Addon cbs dataentry CBS Issues CBS Keys CBS Migration CBS Review Minutes CBS Roll out Plan CBS Total cbs viewer CBSE CBTM CC Bridge CCC ccleaner CCS Rules CCTV Central Government Employees Central Govt Jobs Central Information Commission Central Pensioners Central Provident Fund CEPT FTP cept Mysore Certificate CGEGIS CGHS Change Management Charge Report check list Cheque Child Care Leave Children Education Allowance Chrome Addon Circle Relaxation committe Circular and Orders CIS Citizen Charter Clarification Classification of Posts Coaching Class COD Collection of SB Orders Commemorative Cover Commemorative Stamps Communication Commuted Pension Compassionate Cases Compensation Competition Complaints Computer Advance Computerization Condemnation Guidelines Conduct Rules Conference Config file generator Constitution Consumer Price Index Convention Copyright Cotanct Details Court Case CPAO CPC CPC Software CPF CPGRAMS CPMG CPSMS Fund Transfers CRC RMS CSI CSI Tools CTS Scan Current Affairs Customer Care Customs Declaration CWC Cycle Allowance DA News DA orders Daily Wages Dak Adalat DARPAN Data Migration Centre Data Profiler Data Profiling Tool Database Backup Tool Database File Viewer DB Tools DBA Consolidated report DBA Updater DBA Updater and Mailer DBAnalyzer DCL error Dearness Relief Death Claims Declaration on Parcel Deduction of Tax at Source Demonetisation Department of Disability Affairs Department of Expenditure Department of Personnel & Training Department of Posts Department of Revenue Departmental Canteens Departmental Examination Departmental Promotion Committee depatch error Deputation despatch despatch error & Solution DET DGS&D dharn Dharna Programme Diary Software DIGIFRANK DigiLocker Digital Certificate Digital India Digital Payment Digital Signature Digitization Director General Directorate Directorate Order Disabilities Disciplinary Action Discount Discrepancies tool Discripencies tool Disk Cleaner Dly_select_EVPForIssuingtoPostaman DM Tool DM Utility Dmail dmcc DMMS DMSL DMSS DOP Browser DOP Clients Configuration dop corner dop news DOP Order DOP Tools dopcalc DoPT Downloader Downloads DPC DPMS DPT Fix Draft drivers backup Duplicate Certificates Duplicate Passbook Duties of Postmaster e- Newsletter e-Daily account e-Service Book Earned Leave eBooks eCertificate eCommerce eCommerce Customers edarpan EFMS EFPO eIPO Election Commission of India email emfs Sanchaypost eMO eMO Client emo client error emo error eMonitoring of Letterboxes Employment News ENC Encashment of EL Enumeration EOD ePay Sellers ePayment ePayment Cheque ePayment error ePayment updates EPF EPFO ePost ePost Office Equal pay for equal work eSampark EST Tool Establishment eVPP ewaste Exam Materials Exam Result examination Excel Calculation Sheet Exhibition Express Parcel Express Parcel Net Extension Converter Fake Appointment Fake News Festival Advance File Rename File Zilla finacle Financial Powers Financial Year Firefox Fixed Medical Allowance Fixed Monetary Compensation Fixed Stationary Charges Fixit Flood Advances FMenu Folder Lock Fonts Foreign Articles Foreign Mail Foreign Post Offices Foreign Postage Foreign Tour Foreign Visit Form 60 forms Franchised outlet Freeware Software Frequently Asked Questions FSC FTO Function Keys Gangajal Gazette Notification Gazetted Officers GDS GeM portal General General Financial Rules GEO Tagging GL Code glink GLIS Gmail GO Live Gold Bonds Gold Coins google Google Chrome google drive Google input Tools Google Maps Governance Government Employee Government Offices Govt. Orders GPF GPS Enabled Vehicle GPS Tracker in Letter Box GPSC Gradation List Grade Pay Gratuity Greetings Grievance Group A Group B Group C Group D Group Leader GST Guidelines GUP HACXFRSC Hand book Handheld Device Happy Counter HDMS Hijackthis Hiren Boot HISCOD History of Post Offices holiday Holiday Homes Home Loan Honorarium House Building Advance HP Call Logging Process HP Drivers hp error HP Support HR HRA IFS eMO IFS MO IM Portal Image Converter Image Resizer IMO IMT Inbox Sharing Incentives Income and Cost of BOs Income Tax Increment India Post India Post Ad India Post Help Centre India Post Logo India Post Mail India Post Mobile Application India Post Partners India Post Products Indian Economy Indian Oil Indian Science Congress IndiaPost Mail Indira Vikas Patra infosys Patch for DOP Inland Letter Card Inspection of Posts Inspection Questionnaire Inspection Tool Inspector Inspector of Posts Instructor interest calculation interest calculator interest Posting Interest Posting error Interest Posting Tool interest Rate International Balloon Festival International Postal Articles International Women's day International Yoga day Internet Explorer Internet Users IP Ping Tool IP Scanner IP/ASP Cadre IPO IPO Examination IPoS IPPB IPR IPS IPS bridge ISRO IT Calculation Sheet IT Modernisation IT Team Jan Suraksha Scheme Java JCM Jeevan Pramaan Judgement Just for you Kendriya Vidyalayas KPI KVP KVS KYC Labour and Employment Languages Latest News about 7th Pay Commission Leave Letter Box Letter Writing Competition LGO Examination LIC Life Certificate Local Area Network Local Speed Post article Logistic Post Lok Sabha Q &A Lokpal Act LPG Subsidy LSG Promotion LTC Lync Client Application MAC & IP Address MAC ID Changer MacCamish MACP MACP in Pay Commission Mahamaham Mail Overseer Mails Main Computing Device Maintenance Work at CEPT malware fighter Manual Data Migration Mapping of Post Offices Maternity Leave maxthon McCamish MDE Media Player Medical Allowances Medical Facilities Medical Reimbursement Meghdoot Millennium Meghdoot module issues Meghdoot Post Cards Meghdoot Printer Meghdoot Update Membership MGNREGS Microsoft Edge Minimum Wages Ministry of Communications Ministry of Communications & IT Ministry of Finance Ministry of Women and Child Development MM 7 Update 8 MM 7 Update 9 MM 7 Update 9.1 MM 7 Update 9.2 MM 7 Updated 9.10 MM 7 Updated 9.4 MM 7 Updated 9.6 MM 7.0 Update-8 MM Solutions MM Update MM Update 7.9.3 MM Update 7.9.4 MM Update 7.9.5 MM Update 7.9.7 MM Update 7.9.8 MM Update 7.9.9 MM Updater MM7.0 Update 6 error mm7.3 errors MM7.3 Update 6 error MNC MNOP MNOP Scripts MO Compilation Mo Videsh Mobile Banking Mobile Drivers Mobile Money Transfer Mobile tracking Model representation Money gram Money Order Form ms office MS Word MSDTC MSY Accounts MTS MTS Results Mumbai Postal Mutual Transfer MyStamp National Anthem National Postal Week National Sorting Hub National Sports Awards NDTV NEET Negative List Updation Net Banking network Network migration New exe New Pension Scheme New Scheme New Services News newupdate NIC PLI Bridge NISM NIT NJCA Meeting NJCM Nomenclature Nomination Notification NPO Report NPS NREGAEMO error NREGAEMO update NSC NSC Data Entry Tool NSS NTLDR Missing OBC Office Memorandum Office of Memorandum Official Site Online Recruitment Online Shopping Online Test Online Training Oracle Organ Donation OROP Outlook Outsource Agents Over Time Allowance overflow PA / SA Salary PA 17 Tool PA Examination PACS PAIS Software Pamphlet PAN Paperless Department Parcel Hub Parcel Net Parcel Processing Centre Parcel Revenue Partition Tool passbook printer Passbook Verification Passenger Reservation System Passport Offices Passport Seva Kendras Password Policy Patch Deployment Paternity Leave Pay Commission Pay Commission Calculator Pay Fixation Pay Revision Payment Bank Payment of TA Payments Bank PDF Converter Pension Pension Calculator Pensioners Association Penta Mobile Performance appraisal Performance Tool Periodical Review PF Deduction PF Interest PFRDA News PG Portal Philately Physically Challenged Persons PIB Pickup Service pincode Pledge PLI PLI Bonus PLI Calculator PLI Customer portal PLI Online PLI RPLI PLI/RPLI PLI/RPLI Ledger view PLi/RPLI Service Tax Calculator PMGSKR PMJJBY PMSBY PO Buildings PO Tools point of sale POS Back Office pos error POS Machine POSB Calculator POSB Limits POSB Manuals Post Bank of India Post Info Post Office post office work flow Post Shoppe Postal Address Postal Assistants Postal Calenders / Diaries Postal Championship Postal day Postal ID Card Postal interest calculator Postal Life Insurance Postal Products for Selling Postal Quarters Postal Rate Calculator Postal Scam Postal Service Board Postcard Postinfo Postman postman error Postman Mobile Application Postman Result Postmaster Cadre Postmaster Grade I Postmaster Grade II Postmaster Grade III Postmen PoT Intimation PoTools Android PPF PPF Calculator PPT Pradhan Mantri Fasal Beema Yojna Pre-Migration Preservation and Disposal of Records Press Note printer Printer drivers Printer Spooler Profile Proforma Project Arrow Project Management Promote Hindi Promotions Proof of Identity Provident Fund PT Plugins PT Tools PTC ptc exl for errors ptc links ptc solutions Public Notice Queries Quick Links R Net Communication R Net MIS rabin Rail Booking System Railway rajesh Rajya Sabha Ransomware Rates of DA RBI RD RD Bulk Account Open RD Customer Package RD Data Conversion rd Deposit error Ready Reckoner recover MSDB Recovery tools Recruitment Recruitment in APS Recruitment rules Redeployment of Posts Register dll tool Reimbursement Remittance of Cash remote desktop Remuneration Pay Rent Free Quarters Reservation Resignation Results Retirement Retiring Room Revenue Revenue Stamp RICOH RList RMFS RNet Communication Road Mileage Rotational Transfer Rough Account Sheet RPC error RPLI Bonus RPLI Calculator RRB RTI Rule 3 Rule 38 Rules Rules for SC/ST Rulings Rural ICT SA Help Desk Sa Tools Salary Salary Advance Sales and Marketing Same day delivery Sanchay Post Sanchay Post 7.5 Sanchay Post Tools Sanchay Post View Mode Sanchaypost error SAP Savings Scheme sb SB Apptitude SB Discrepancies Tools SB Live Account Report SB Orders SB Statistical Tool SB46 Intimation tool sbco SBCO Utility SBI Buddy SC/ST promotion Scan to PDF Scanner drivers schedule schedule backup Schedule of Charges Screenshot script Tool SCS SI Entries sdc updates SDI Secretary Security Senior Citizen Schemes Seniority List Sensitive Posts Service Desk Service Tax services Sexual Harassment SGB Sharing Files Shortcut Shortcut Keys Sify Signage board Signature Scanner Signature Tools Single Sign On smart driver backup SMR SMS SO Slip so to ho Social Media softwares Solar Panel for BOs Solution for DM Utility Solution for DPT Discrepancies Sorting hub updation SOSB Tools Sovereign Gold Bond SP Patch updater SPARROW SPCC Data SPCOD Special Arrangements Special CL Special Cover special journal Special RTI Stamps Speed Net 3.1.2 Speed Net 4.0 Speed Net 4.1 Speed Net 4.1.1 Speed Net 4.2 Speed Net 4.3 Speed Net 4.3.1 Speed Net 4.4 Speed Net 4.4 Update 1 Speed Net 4.4 Update 2 Speed Net 4.5 Speed Net 4.6 Speed Post Speednet Communication SpeedNet error Speednet Tool Speednet update SpeedNet Update Status speedpost tariff revision Sports Sports Quota Notification Spouse Employment SPVM SQL SQL 2000 Suspect sql 2008 SQL and windows sql backup sql error SQL Query for Post Office SQL Recovery SQL Restore SR Tools Sr.Postmaster SSA SSA Calculator SSC SSC CHSL 2015 SSC CHSL 2016 SSC CHSL 2017 SSC CHSL 2018 ssms Stamps Standard Operating Procedures State Bank of India statement ste Stenographers STP strike Sub Account sub accounts Sub Division Submit account Subscribe Substitutes Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana Supplementary Supreme Court Order Survey Swachh Bharat Campaign Swachh Bharat Service Tax Switch to retry error switchto error Syllabus Syllabus for PA Examination symantec sysadmintools System Administrator System Utilities TA Allowance TA Bill Software tariff revision Tariff updation Tax Deduction at Source TCB TD Commission TDS TDS Software Team viewer full version Technology Telangana Postal Circle Telegram telnet Template Tender Tenure TeraCopy Theft cases Thunderbird Timeout Error in SQL tips TN Circle News TNEB error TNF Location TNPSC Toll Free Tool bar remover Tool for DOP Employee Tool for eMO Tool for Holidays 2014 Tool for Holidays 2015 Tool for Holidays 2016 tournaments Track and Trace tracking Trade Union Trail Closure Training Training Allowances Training Calendar Training Centre Training Materials Transaction Holiday Transfer Transfer / Posting of IPS Transfer / Posting Order Transfer Mobile Contacts Transfer Policy Transport allowance Travelling Allowance Treasurer Treasury treasury error trial TTUM tutorial Typing Software UA Clearance UIDAI Uniforms uninstaller union Union News UPSC USB Format USB Port usefulpost User Guides User Registration v2sbco Vacancies Value Added Services VBDET VC on CBS VC on Technical Issues Vehicle for Postman Verification tool Version Regeneration Video Tutorials Videos Vigilance Virtual bag Virtual Currencies Virtual Printer Virus Removal tool Voluntary Retirement Scheme VP Article VP Intimation we Web Links Weblink Welfare WhatsApp window 7 Windows 10 windows 2003 server windows 2003 server update Windows 7 windows 7 error Windows 8 Windows Application Windows Edge windows error windows server 2008 windows server troubleshooting Windows Services windows troubleshooting Windows XP winrar Wireman WNX WNX Tariff Revision Woman Post Offices Working hours Workman Workshop WOS Currency Notes writer WTC WUMT Youtube
Back To Top